School board orders cut in teachers’ pay
E.P. Teachers Pay Cut
The game of hardball continues between the East Providence school committee and the teachers union.EAST PROVIDENCE, R.I.—An across-the-board pay cut for East Providence teachers went into effect Monday.
The school committee went forward with an aggressive plan to balance the budget by slashing salaries and forcing teachers to pay more for benefits.
The move came after months of contract negotiations went nowhere.
“We don’t have any money,“ said school committee chairman Anthony Carcieri. “There is no money. How are we going to pay a bloated contract?“
The committee went ahead with plans to slash teacher salaries by 5 percent and collect 20 percent of the cost of health care premiums.
The union immediately hit back, filing a complaint with the state labor board.
“They’re asking teachers to fund East Providence. They’re asking them to take a lot less and pay a lot more in health care than they’ve asked other municipal employees,“ said Larry Purtill, president of the National Education Association Rhode Island. “We’re just asking to be treated the same.”
According to City Manager Richard Brown, the school department is solely responsible for the deficit, but he said teachers aren’t the only ones taking a hit.
“We’re looking at making major alterations in the way we staff our fire department,“ Brown said. “We have reduced the number of take-home vehicles. We’ve stopped spending on additional vehicles. Every single item is being scrutinized.“
Brown said he’s only concerned with the bottom line, which is $4.5 million in the hole.
“We are in danger of not being able to continue to pay our bills,“ Brown said.
The matter will most likely be decided by the courts. The decision will be closely watched by cash-strapped municipalities and unions fearful of losing ground.
Advertisement
Reader Reactions
Does the East Providence School Committee have the legal authority to take this action? If so, what’s to stop other cities and towns from following suit? This could become a real mess that could take millions of dollars to resolve.
Welcome to the real world and paying a portion for health insurance!
How many people are working 2 or even 3 jobs and still can NOT afford insurance for their famililes, and teachers complain? All of us have been paying our dues for years & years .. bout time teachers catch up with the times. With people losing their jobs every second teachers complain about a 5% pay cut ... would they rather be unemployed?
Personally I had to take a 20% paycut & increase in health insurance and I’m still GRATEFUL for having a job with benefits!
Condemnation is in fact the environment we are all living in. I have no problem with teachers or anyone who works in an environment where seniority, group negotiations, and contracts are a reality. That is there chosen field. Not place to tell someone where to work and what to do for a career. In fact, and to be frank, I considered becoming a teacher, but I have an aversion to whining and to people who whine all too often.
However, most of us do not live in the environment of the minority you are championing. Do not expect sympathy from the many when you are asked to take a 5% pay cut and pay a small portion of your healthcare. Many of the lucky who are still employed must walk into work on a daily basis wondering if today is the day the “expense” cuts come down. If one is fortunate enough to survive, he or she will be greatly rewarded with an increase to workload for no additional pay. If these people do not want to take a pay cut, an option not often given, let some of them go. Problem is simply solved. Simple math: RI has a 10% unemployment rate right now. 5% < 10%.
On point continues to stick, if these teachers are unhappy with their new contracts, why can they not look for employment elsewhere?
misterkennie, you must be a very sad, envious person who wishes reality was your ‘enlightened’ vision. Quit hiding behind a pseudonym if you are going to condemn decent hard working people.
People who have chosen careers in the fantasy worlds of non-profits, education, or social service have no real concept of how most people live. Contract disputes? Who has contracts? Free healthcare? What a deal. The proper solution is to take a real world approach and layoff a bunch of these teachers. I find this hilarious that this nonsense even makes headline news when probably about 3000 people will be laid-off in RI and MA during this upcoming year between three large institutions one can find in Providence. You have to read the business section to know about that. I would love to take a 5% pay cut if it meant a guaranteed position.
Simple solution, if there is a fight over the 5% pay cut, lay-off 5% off the work force. Better yet, do not base lay-offs on seniority, another joke of a system, and cut some of teachers who only remain passionless at there positions for a fat paycheck and the summer off. Simply put, 20% for healthcare is a good deal. If these teachers are so unhappy, they can do what any worker in the private sector does, suck it up and deal or look for a new job.
Listen i am not here to argue,and i never implied that teaching is a dream job. All i am saying is that we should be thankful that we are working and have money comming in.Plain and simple. We all choose where we work. and We all choose our careers. And we all have opinions, doesn’t mean we have to like them. Again i am not here to argue seems like you are.. this is where we can voice our opinions and leave it at that, not respond with rude or hate like comments.
Try being a teacher for just one year, then come back and tell us how easy it was caring about the kids, preparing for the kids, doing this under federally unfunded mandates while also trying to please administrators who sometimes don’t have a clue of how to get the job done. I say ‘job’, but it is really a lifetime commitment. Oh yes and prepare to voluntarily give up any kind of social life during week nights & week ends, dutifully fulfilling your commitments as a dedicated teacher. Don’t forget the thousands of dollars & hours advancing your education & skills WELL beyond a Masters degree. You know what? Why not pay teachers the equivalent pay of lawyers & other professionals at that same level of education & experience? I’m sure everyone would be completely satisfied then. Maybe you would rather we go back to the ‘Good Old Days’ when teachers were spinsters who were expected to find a family to live with, in the town they were teaching. Teachers obviously never really needed unions! They should have stayed the second class citizens they were suppose to be. After all they were only entrusted with the future of our country.
Dear CBSNA:
First of all, let me state that I never claimed to be an “expert” on this or any topic. I am allowed to give my opinion just as you. I do not expect you or anyone else to agree with my views on this topic. It’s simply “my opinion”.
Secondly, I most certainly would have the skills and brains to become a certified teacher but chose to enter into another field. I never said one bad thing about teachers. There are many qualified, caring teachers in this country and they should be valued. However, I do think it’s time to come to the realization that this country is in trouble and we all should take some of the burden (such as healthcare costs). Not just the chosen few. I think it quite childish of you to attack my qualifications and schooling without knowing anything about me. I would think that someone who makes over $100K a year has somewhat of a brain-don’t you agree? Maybe it was that great teaching I received….
Hi sburke!
You, too, are part of the great unwashed. Why don’t you have the qualifications to be a certified teacher??? You could solve all the problems! Methinks you couldn’t pass the GED to pretend you are a high school graduate! Thanks for your “expert” comments!
Jessica,
I want to know if you consider teaching a “dream job”? If so, where and at what level do you teach at your “dream job” nad how many years have you been at this “dream job”? My guess is that you are a drone at some drudge position not even related to education and are so jealous of a teaching position that you are not even qualified for.
Do you hsve the guts to answer????














Advertisement